UncommonGoods

search


Space

Pluto on the Rebound

Many years later, Venus still has a soft spot for Pluto
by Saeeda Hafiz
21 February 2007 Comments 5 Comments

Pluto on the Rebound
Image: Anne Casselman
Pluto on the Rebound   Print Pluto on the Rebound   Email Pluto on the Rebound   Digg

Related Books

Out here in the solar system, we planets are none too happy about what’s happened to poor Pluto. I tried to give him some TLC, but it didn’t work. He’s mad. “Venus,” he said, “I feel like a downsized employee. How could I be hailed as a planet since 1930 and then just let go after some corporate science meeting?”

Mercury sped to Pluto’s defense. “We should have organized when Mars asked us to; too bad we thought he was a troublemaker – God of War and all that. Now none of us are safe.”

Neptune wondered why, in a universe where executives pocket hefty salaries without MBAs, and entertainers win honorary doctorates from top-notch schools, Pluto couldn’t have been grandfathered into the solar system.

The way Pluto sees it, he’s been orbiting around the Sun forever and was a member of the family for 76 years. And now, all of sudden, he’s a celestial body with insufficient mass. He’s having trouble even talking to juiced-up Jupiter and flashy Saturn with all her rings, as if body mass and bling were a job requirement.

He even left me feeling guilty. Long ago, he asked me to marry him and if I hadn’t turned him down, at least he would have the spousal rights of a planet. All he ever wanted was to live a simple life providing a humble, yet valuable contribution to the Solar System.

Uranus thinks it’s all Earth’s fault. “Why does Earth get to make all the rules? He’s actually destroying himself with a lousy diet, all that CO2, not to mention threats of nuclear war.”

From where I orbit, Pluto doesn’t want special treatment. He just wants to keep his job and his job title. And besides, he’s not going anywhere.

Love, Venus (a.k.a Saeeda Hafiz)

Comments 5 Comments | Pluto on the Rebound   Print | Pluto on the Rebound   Email | Pluto on the Rebound   Digg Share

Related Articles





Comments

As much as it pains me to say it, even though I too have grown up with a soft spot for Pluto (and I always will), the crazy thing about science is how laws are disproven, how dogma is thwarted, and how changes are made to what were once common beliefs. Take organism taxonomy, for example. Organisms are being regrouped and reordered on a daily basis, depending on new definitions of what is considered "related." Similarly, it was inevitable that we would one day define new rules on what it means to be a planet.

So though you might not have agreed on the decision, it has been made (though I won't get into the politics here) by the appropriate authoritative scientific body. And so we must learn to change our beliefs. On the up-side, we'll be able to say that we lived during that time when Pluto was considered a planet. That's worth something.

Since when does size matter?! Well, at least as far as planets go. I think Pluto should retain planet status if, for no other reason, it has BEEN a planet for so long...kinda like common law marriage. Maybe instead of demoting planets we need to redefine what it is to be a planet. I for one am ready and willing to stand up for the little guy.

I think the point about Pluto's demotion is that it proves that such a seemingly "simple" thing as a planet wasn't well-defined at all by astronomers.

Makes you wonder how many other things are just taken for granted.

Well, he may have retired from the solar system, but at least he'll get a visitor when New Horizons swings past in a few years.

They've been quick to demote poor Pluto, too. I bought my son a glossy picture book of the planets and Pluto has been shoved off to a back chapter with the other "ice worlds".

My four-year-old looked up at me with brimming eyes and said, "Where's Pluto?"

"Here it is, son. Reduced to an appendix. After all these years. You think having three moons would count for something. And maybe it did. Maybe the Earth's just jealous and had to administer a smack-down on tiny, icy Pluto."

'Dwarf-planet!' Geez, you think they'd at least use the phrase 'radially-challenged'.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.